The Top 8 Disaster
With the Super League fixtures for 2026 being announced this week, we will likely learn whether we will be returning to having a top 8 play off system. This is the system currently used by the NRL and used by us between 2009 and 2014. In this blogpost, I will explain why I believe this would be a terrible move. It isn't very Rugby League to mention this (as we often value entertainment over equity) but fairness is a real issue under this system. Of course, these things are a balance and many believe it is right to prioritise entertainment. In my view , any system with an uneven fixture list is also inequitable. As is the side finishing top of league potentially seeing a season's work go up in smoke with one bad performance (which can happen under our existing system). As a sport, we have made the decision to sacrifice elements of equity in the pursuit of entertainment. That is a legitimate aim, even if you do not agree with it. A top 8 system amplifies the unfairness to an e...